Do youth ministers indoctrinate kids?
October 11, 2006
This week seems to be a good time to discuss the issue of
indoctrinating kids into religious faith. On Friday, October 6th, the movie Jesus Camp opened in Austin and
about a dozen or so ACA members went to one of the opening night showings. The
movie plays at the Arbor through October 12th. The movie looked behind the
scenes at a Pentecostal camp for kids, called the "Kids on Fire Summer Camp." They
gave a lot of attention to youth Pastor Becky Fischer, who runs the camp. She
leaves no doubt in the mind of the viewer that she is out to indoctrinate those
kids for belief in Christianity and use them as little missionaries for God.
The informal after-movie discussion by ACA members included some dialogue as to
what exactly constituted child abuse in this context. It was very clear that
the children in the Jesus Camp movie were emotionally manipulated and had their
critical thinking skills sabotaged. It was unclear to what extent the less
extreme youth ministries also use these tactics.
Ironically, also last week, Austin hosted a conference of youth
ministers at the Austin Convention Center from October 5th through the 9th. The
conference, called 2006
National Youth Workers Convention, had an attendance of about 3000. I'll
bet many of the convention attendees actually saw the Jesus Camp movie in
Austin. It would be interesting to gauge their reactions to the movie and
learn which of Becky Fischer's techniques they use.
If I had the ear of 3000 youth ministers, I'd ask them about
how they teach the story of Noah's Ark. The story of the flood is a
black-and-white moral lesson: genocide is blatantly wrong. The Bible story
is a means teach basic morality. So I'd ask the youth ministers
whether they took advantage of the golden opportunity to teach the young minds
in their care about basic moral principles. I imagine, however, that most youth
ministers work hard to excuse the actions of Yahweh in the Bible as somehow
just and good. After all, God grants tickets to heaven. You wouldn't want to piss him off. So, the flood story beomes about cute little furry animals taking a boat ride. I think it's terribly sad that so many Christian parents think
their children are getting a moral education from youth ministers.
Apparently, whatever tactics are used by youth ministers
don't work very well. On October 6th New York Times piece titled "Evangelicals
Fear the Loss of Their Teenagers," reported that evangelical teens are
abandoning the faith in droves. They have dubbed this phenomenon "the 4% panic
attack," which allegedly is the percentage of evangelical kids who will grow up
to be true "Bible Believers." Predictably, evangelical leaders blame sex,
drugs, rock & roll, and popular culture. It couldn't possibly be the case
that when kids acquire critical thinking skills, they realize that there is
nothing there of substance, or could it? A majority of ACA members were once
Christians--many were even quite serious about it. If we figured it out,
perhaps others can, too. Nobody seems to ask whether being a "bible believer"
is a good thing though, like most religious definitions, there
seems to be a lot of debate about what it means.
Predictably, the Austin American Statesman dodged the deeper
issues and published a pro-Christian puff piece on the dedication of youth
ministers. Eileen Flynn's "Leading
kids to CHRIST" was published October 7th. (It's not at all clear why
Christ is in all capital letters, but it sure catches the eye.) While the
dedication of the ministers might be admirable, nobody would question the
dedication of Pastor Becky Fisher from the Jesus Camp movie. The issue of
dedication lacks substance. Flynn's article focused on the clothing styles of
the ministers and adroitly dodged the issue of indoctrination and what moral
lessons are being taught to youth. There was no mention of the Jesus Camp
movie, despite the obvious connection. The article did have several paragraphs
attempting to debunk the 4% statistic, though Statesman readers were largely
left in the dark as to what the controversy was about. The Statesman never
published anything else about the New York Times piece. Eileen Flynn, the youth
ministers, and even members of the Atheist Community of Austin are in the know
about religion precisely because we don't depend on the Statesman for
substantive religion news. Everyone else, it seems, gets pabulum.
From the officers:
The ACA Lecture Series continues Sunday, October 11th at 12:15pm in the Austin History Center, 9th and Guadalupe. The building opens at noon. Texas Freedom Network's Dan Quinn will give us an update on their activities. The lecture is free and open to the public.